On Audiobooks in Libraries
Wednesday, February 27th, 2008The Chicago Public Library is diving into downloadable audiobooks with the launch of its new OverDrive service. The OverDrive site says right at the top, “Download digital audio books to your personal computer anytime, day or night. All you need is a library card!”
However, there are a few big caveats.
First, the OverDrive software is based upon the horribly-designed Windows Media Player, its wildly unpopular formats and its odious DRM, so Mac and Linux users are out of luck. The help pages state that “…in order to use OverDrive Audio Book titles on a device, the device must play DRM-protected Windows Media content,” so many portable MP3 players are out of luck, too.
Second, the audiobooks are not compatible with iPods which, comprise 70% of the portable music players out there. Now, this is neither CPL’s nor OverDrive’s fault; rather, it is Apple’s, for exclusively supporting Audible audiobooks.
Third and most disappointing, these audiobooks can’t be downloaded by too many people at one time and expire automatically. According to the article, “After three weeks, the files no longer work, essentially ‘returning’ themselves. And like regular library books, only limited copies of the audiobook are available, and waits for some books aren’t unusual.” (emphasis mine) Yes, you read that right; if a book gets popular, you can’t download it until someone else’s copy is returned.
Chicago Public Library is taking a remarkably (or perhaps “unreasonably” is a better word) rosy view of a digital audiobook system which excludes so many people and makes the rest jump through so many hoops. “Who we expect [to download books] is Chicagoans of all ages…but especially commuters and joggers,” said Chicago Public Library spokeswoman Tanya King.
Sure; all of those commuters and joggers we see on the el who don’t have an iPod, who are running Windows Media Player and who are willing to subject themselves to this kind of nonsense just to listen to an audiobook. What in the world is going on when a digital download is treated as a finite resource, like a physical copy of a book, and what happens to people who haven’t listened to a whole book when the expiry date comes up?
Now, CPL has one compromise; a small portable audiobook player called a Playaway, which holds one book and which you check out and return like a normal book. That isn’t as bad (I suppose), but it’s still a silly hoop to jump through, just to hear someone read a book.
